Dark & Stormy sounds foreboding, but it’s actually named after the murky color of the drink, similar to storm clouds rolling in. This is easiest to see when you pour the rum and it hasn’t mixed into the ginger beer yet.
This post may contain affiliate links. This post is meant for those of legal drinking age.
What is Dark & Stormy ?
The Dark & Stormy is a rum highball that’s easy to make, as long as you have the right ingredients. In theory all you need is a dark or black rum, ginger beer, and lime juice (optional). In practice, the rum you need is very specific: Gosling’s Black Seal rum. It’s a Bermuda rum with strong caramel and vanilla notes, and they actually trademarked the Dark ‘N’ Stormy drink.
However in the privacy of your own home, no one will open a lawsuit against you. You can use whichever dark or black rum you prefer. The only issue is when a bar (or another rum company) tries to sell or advertise a drink named Dark ‘N’ Stormy without using Gosling’s Black Seal rum.
There is something to be said about black rum versus dark rum. It’s richer in flavor and has a stronger color, but if you’re using dark you will still get a very close approximation.
- 2 oz black or dark rum
- 0.5 oz lime juice
- ginger beer to top (about 4 oz)
- lime to garnish
- Build in glass, Collings or highball, filled with ice.
- Pour in ginger beer and lime juice.
- Pour in black rum on top, do not stir.
- Serve while still cloudy-looking, garnish with lime wheel.
- I scaled down the recipe for this as I used a smaller glass. I used 1 oz rum, 2 oz ginger beer, 0.25 lime juice. The ratio is the same, just the size is different.
- It's called dark and stormy as a nod to the cloudy look it gets when you pour in the dark rum. Sometimes it doesn't mix as it sinks, and looks like billowing storm clouds.
- Do stir right before drinking, the no-stir is there just for show.
When is this drink best ?
As a rum cooler, I think Dark & Stormy works great as a summery drink, but the ginger beer in it I think makes it good year-round. It’s a bit of a casual drink, so I could see it at an office party, in a bar, in a club, on the menu of a pool bar, or just chilling in the backyard. There’s not much fuss to it.
My thoughts on Dark & Stormy
I found the Dark & Stormy quite pleasant, and not nearly as sweet as the color would suggest. The sweetness is entirely dependent on your ginger beer, and mine wasn’t very sweet to begin with, but the rum has a beautiful caramel-vanilla note to it that fooled me into thinking it’s a little sweeter.
You could serve this without lime juice, but I think it elevates the drink and gives it a zing that it’s otherwise missing.
If you like Dark & Stormy, you might also like…
Anejo Highball – dark rum highball with just the right amount of lime juice
Foghorn – gin and ginger beer highball
Notes, substitutes, and tips
The lime juice here is optional but really it makes it better. If you’re serving several guests, you can skip the lime juice when building and instead offer a lime wedge with each drink, so each person can add as little or as much lime as they want.
You need ginger beer, not ale for this. Neither is alcoholic, but ginger beer is an actual fermented ginger drink while ginger ale is carbonated water flavored with ginger.
When pouring your rum over the ginger, it may or may not immediately mix. Ideally it won’t mix easily, forming darker and lighter patches, along with the ginger beer and ice cubes, like a cloudy sky. Do not stir this when serving, but do mix it right before you drink.